http://www3.interscience.wiley.com/journal/117998847/abstract
Journal of Religious Ethics
Volume 35 Issue 3, Pages 403 - 428
Published Online: 9 Aug 2007
© 2008 Journal of Religious Ethics, Inc.
Get Sample Copy
Recommend to Your Librarian
Save journal to My Profile
Set E-Mail Alert
Email this page
Print this page
RSS web feed (What is RSS?)
< Previous Abstract Next Abstract >
Save Article to My Profile Download Citation
Abstract References Full Text: HTML, PDF (112k) Related Articles Citation Tracking
AQUINAS ON ATTACHMENT, ENVY, AND HATRED IN THE SUMMA THEOLOGICA
Keith Green 1
1 East Tennessee State University
Copyright 2007 Journal of Religious Ethics, Inc.
KEYWORDS
attachment • envy • hatred • bigotry • passions • emotion • love • Aquinas
ABSTRACT






This essay examines Aquinas's discussions of hatred in Summa Theologica I-II, Q. 29 and II-II, Q. 34, in order to retrieve an account of what contemporary theorists of the emotions call its cognitive contents. In Aquinas's view, hatred is constituted as a passion by a narrative pattern that includes its intentional object, beliefs, perceptions of changes in bodily states, and motivated desires. This essay endorses Aquinas's broadly "cognitivist" account of passional hatred, in line with his way of treating passions in general. I suggest that Aquinas's account of hatred's arising out of attachment is compelling. However, I also argue that if Aquinas's treatment of hatred is to help us understand the phenomenon of hate, where classes of people are abominated for an identity they bear, and to avoid equating an oppressor's hatred with that of the oppressed for the oppressor, the cognitive pathway to hatred must be broader than through envy.